Skip to content
itsorted.online
Cybersecurity guide

Microsoft Secure Score: What It Means and What to Fix First

Microsoft Secure Score is the percentage in the Microsoft Defender portal that rates how well your Microsoft 365 tenant is configured. Small businesses often see 30% or 40% and panic, or chase 100% and break things. Neither helps. The score counts points for recommended settings, it includes recommendations for products you may not own, and some items matter far more than others. This guide explains how the score is calculated, which actions to fix first in a small tenant, how to handle recommendations your licence doesn't cover or that don't fit your business, and a simple monthly routine.

By IT Sorted teamReviewed 6 min readHow we write guides
in

Key takeaways

  • Each recommended action is worth 10 points or less; some give partial points per user or device.
  • Turning on security defaults gives full points for three key MFA and legacy-auth actions.
  • Secure Score shows recommendations for products regardless of your licence; use the Current license score view.
  • Mark actions as risk accepted or resolved through a third party, with a reason, rather than ignoring them.
  • Check the score monthly and investigate any drop; it can signal a change someone made.
In this guide · 7 sections
  1. 01How Microsoft Secure Score is calculated
  2. 02Why small business tenants score low
  3. 03What to fix first in a small tenant
  4. 04Accepting risk and third-party mitigations
  5. 05Tracking Secure Score monthly
  6. 06Do it yourself or get help?
  7. 07Frequently asked questions

Short answer

Secure Score is a points total for recommended Microsoft 365 security settings. Don't chase 100%. Fix MFA for everyone, MFA for admins and blocking legacy authentication first first, then use the Current license score view to see what's realistic.

How Microsoft Secure Score is calculated

Microsoft's Secure Score documentation explains the mechanics. You find the score in the Microsoft Defender portal under Exposure management or Secure Score.

  • You earn points for configuring recommended security features, doing security tasks, or addressing a recommendation with a non-Microsoft tool or alternate mitigation.
  • Each recommended action is worth 10 points or less. Most are all-or-nothing; some give partial points, for example MFA on 50 of 100 users earns half the points.
  • Recommendations cover Microsoft Entra ID, Exchange Online, SharePoint, Teams, Defender for Endpoint and Office, and some third-party apps.
  • The score updates in real time, and syncs daily for achieved points. Microsoft notes that Entra recommendations refresh weekly and Teams recommendations monthly, as well as on configuration changes.

The percentage is your points divided by the maximum possible. Because the maximum includes recommendations for products you may not own, a well-run small tenant can still show a modest percentage.

Why small business tenants score low

Microsoft says it shows the full set of possible recommendations for a product "regardless of license edition, subscription, or plan". A Business Basic or Standard tenant therefore sees recommendations that need Entra ID P1 or P2, Defender for Office 365 Plan 2 or Defender for Cloud Apps, and can't earn those points.

Score viewWhat it showsUse it for
Secure ScorePoints achieved out of every possible pointThe headline number
Current license scoreThe score achievable with your current Microsoft licencesA realistic target for your plan
Achievable scoreWhat you can reach with your licences and current risk acceptanceYour actual goal
Planned scoreProjected score once planned actions are doneTracking a project
Views from Microsoft's Secure Score improvement actions page.

Turn on these views under the score breakdown, as described in Microsoft's recommended actions page. For a 10-person office on Business Standard, the achievable score is the number that matters.

What to fix first in a small tenant

Points aren't equal in real-world value. These actions block the attacks that hit small businesses most: stolen passwords, phishing and old sign-in protocols.

  1. Turn on MFA for every user

    If you don't use Conditional Access, turn on Microsoft Entra security defaults. Microsoft says this gives full points for "Ensure all users can complete multifactor authentication" (9 points), "Require MFA for administrative roles" (10 points) and "Enable policy to block legacy authentication" (7 points).

  2. Reduce the number of Global Administrators

    Two to four is plenty for a small business. Give daily admin work a lesser role.

  3. Protect email

    Turn on the recommended anti-phishing, Safe Links and Safe Attachments policies if your licence includes them, and set up DMARC for your domain.

  4. Control external sharing and app consent

    Limit anonymous sharing links in SharePoint and OneDrive, and stop users consenting to unknown apps.

  5. Turn on audit logging

    So you can investigate if an account is compromised.

  6. Then work down the list

    Sort recommended actions by score impact and pick the ones that fit how your business works.

If you have Business Premium, Conditional Access replaces security defaults with finer control; see our Conditional Access guide. Our Microsoft 365 security checklist covers the wider set-up.

Accepting risk and third-party mitigations

Not every recommendation fits a small business. Microsoft's own documentation says security should be balanced with usability. Each action can be given a status: to address, planned, risk accepted, resolved through third party, resolved through alternate mitigation, or completed.

Reasonable to mark

  • Resolved through third party: you use another email filter or endpoint protection that covers it
  • Resolved through alternate mitigation: security defaults cover risk policies Microsoft recommends
  • Risk accepted: a setting that would break a business process, with a written reason
  • Planned: you've scheduled it and want the planned score view

Don't hide these

  • MFA gaps for any user, especially admins
  • Legacy authentication left on for convenience
  • Too many Global Administrators
  • Anonymous sharing links with no expiry

Tracking Secure Score monthly

A score that drops is often more useful than a score that's high. A sudden fall can mean someone turned off a policy, added an admin or enabled a risky setting.

Monthly Secure Score check

Fold this into a wider monthly review; our monthly cyber hygiene checklist lists the other checks worth doing at the same time.

Do it yourself or get help?

Turning on security defaults and trimming admin accounts are DIY-friendly and earn the most important points. Help is worth it when you have Business Premium and want Conditional Access instead, when recommendations touch email flow or sharing that staff rely on, or when you need a defensible record of what you accepted and why.

Our Microsoft 365 / Google Security Lockdown (S$590) works through the recommended actions that fit your licence and business, documents risk acceptances, and leaves you with a report you can show insurers or customers.

Frequently asked questions

There's no universal good number, because the maximum includes recommendations for products you may not license. Turn on the Current license score and Achievable score views and aim to get close to your achievable score. More important than the percentage is that MFA, admin protection and legacy authentication blocking are complete.

Microsoft shows every recommendation for a product regardless of licence, so a Business Basic tenant sees actions that need Entra ID P1 or P2, Defender add-ons or Purview features it doesn't have. Those points can't be earned. Use the Current license score view to see what is achievable with your plan.

Yes. Microsoft says enabling security defaults gives full points for three recommended actions: ensuring all users can complete MFA (9 points), requiring MFA for administrative roles (10 points) and blocking legacy authentication (7 points). It also recommends marking related risk policy actions as resolved through alternative mitigation.

You can mark them as risk accepted, but record why. Microsoft notes that not every recommendation fits every environment. Accept risk for items that would break a genuine business process, and review those decisions periodically. Don't accept risk on MFA, admin account protection or legacy authentication.

Microsoft says the score updates in real time and syncs daily for achieved points. Some recommendation states refresh on configuration changes and on a schedule: weekly for Microsoft Entra recommendations and monthly for Teams. Checking once a month is enough for most small businesses.

Rather have it done for you?

Fixed price, set up in your own accounts.

Order online, get a written scope, and keep full ownership of everything we set up. Questions first? Ask us in writing.